Friday 14 August 2026 Independent · No affiliate links · No sponsored reviews
N Noteworthy Online Games
HomeReviews › Genshin Impact
No. 14 in The Noteworthy 50 · Action RPG

Genshin Impact

A genuinely world-class open-world action RPG, given away free, funded by one of the most effective gacha machines ever built.

HoYoverse· 2020· PC, PlayStation, iOS, Android

It is worth being clear about what HoYoverse achieved here, because the gacha framing causes people to dismiss it. Genshin Impact is a large, hand-authored open world with meaningful verticality, a climbing-and-gliding traversal system lifted intelligently from Breath of the Wild, an elemental combat system with real depth, and a production budget visible in every region. That it runs on a phone and costs nothing to install is remarkable.

The combat is the strongest system. Elements combine — electro into hydro, pyro into cryo — producing reactions with distinct damage profiles, and party building becomes an exercise in engineering a reaction loop. At the high end, players optimise rotations frame by frame. At the casual end you set things on fire and it works fine.

The machine underneath

Characters are acquired through limited-time gacha banners with low base rates and a pity counter that guarantees a five-star eventually — but 'eventually' can be an expensive distance away, and the character you want specifically is a further coin flip. Layered on top is the artifact system, where gear stats are randomised across five slots with no deterministic path to a good roll. Resin then caps how many attempts you get per day. Each of these systems is individually defensible; together they are a precision-engineered engagement and spending funnel.

The free path is genuinely viable — patient players clear all story content with a starter roster — and the six-week update cadence delivers real content without charging for it. But go in knowing the shape of the thing. This is a beautiful game that is also a business built on a small number of people spending a very large amount of money.

What works

  • Exploration and traversal design that stands next to the genre's best
  • Elemental reaction combat is deep, readable and satisfying to master
  • Regular free content on a reliable six-week cadence, no expansion fees
  • Full cross-save between PC, console and mobile, done properly

What doesn't

  • Gacha rates on limited characters are punishing and the pity system is long
  • The artifact grind is a random-number treadmill with no floor
  • Co-op is an afterthought bolted onto a single-player game
  • Resin energy caps how much you can meaningfully play in a day

The Catch — what it will cost you

This is the entry on this list where the monetisation warning matters most. Limited banners run on a soft-pity system that can require a very large number of pulls, and the design is engineered around limited-time character availability. Whales fund the game so everyone else plays free. That is a real gift and a real trap — set a hard spending limit before you install, not after.
Who it's for: Solo explorers who want a beautiful world and can commit to spending nothing.
GachaOpen worldMobileFree to play

If you like this

Review

Honkai: Star Rail

The best-presented turn-based RPG on any platform, running on the same gacha engine you should still be wary of.

8.1 Free No. 23
Review

Warframe

The most generous free-to-play game ever made, and one of the hardest to start playing.

8.4 Free No. 26
Review

Destiny 2

Peerless shooting and raid design, sold through a storefront that seems designed to confuse, by a studio whose future is uncertain.

7.7 No. 20